| 1 | . | Raymond Busch | 1937 |
| 2 | . | Ronne Von Losson | 1940 |
| 3 | . | John Petrie | 1946 |
| 4 | . | Jim Deleri | 1947 |
| 5 | . | Peter Ruddy | 1947 |
| 6 | . | John Lyons | 1950 |
| 7 | . | Jim Peterson | 1950 |
| 8 | . | Jack Rogers | 1950 |
| 9 | . | Earl Morman | 1951 |
| 10 | . | Bill McKinley | 1951 |
| 11 | . | William Block | 1952 |
| 12 | . | William S. Wade, Jr. | 1952 |
| 13 | . | John Olney | 1952 |
| 14 | . | Lyman Newton | 1952 |
| 15 | . | Donald O'Malley | 1953 |
| 16 | . | Kenneth Beckley | 1953 |
| 17 | . | Terry House | 1954 |
| 18 | . | Hubert Busey | 1954 |
| 19 | . | Richard Busey | 1954 |
| 20 | . | George Mason | 1954 |
| 21 | . | Bert Hubenthal | 1954 |
| 22 | . | Don Reidel | 1954 |
| 23 | . | Peter Van Ness | 1954 |
| 24 | . | Gary Cunningham | 1954 |
| 25 | . | Tom Alberg | 1954 |
| 26 | . | Camden Hall | 1954 |
| 27 | . | Sidney Green | 1954 |
| 28 | . | Brian Sweeney | 1955 |
| 29 | . | Brent Sletmoe | 1955 |
| 30 | . | Norman Thordarson | 1955 |
| 31 | . | Jay Cunningham | 1955 |
| 32 | . | Tom North | 1956 |
| 33 | . | Denny Van Ness | 1957 |
| 34 | . | Peter Glase | 1957 |
| 35 | . | Bob Morrison, Jr. | 1957 |
| 36 | . | Jerry King | 1957 |
| 37 | . | Don Berger | 1957 |
| 38 | . | Barry Sonne | 1957 |
| 39 | . | John Sweeney | 1958 |
| 40 | . | Danny Hoogen | 1958 |
| 41 | . | Robert Finne | 1958 |
| 42 | . | Ronald Berry | 1958 |
| 43 | . | Kurtis Carlson | 1958 |
| 44 | . | Steve Gibson | 1959 |
| 45 | . | Kenneth Bowe | 1959 |
| 46 | . | Ray McEachern | 1960 |
| 47 | . | Randall McClory | 1964 |
| 48 | . | Brian Anderson | 1964 |
| 49 | . | Bruce O'Neill | 1964 |
| 50 | . | John Rothermel | 1967 |
51 | . | Bryan Millard | 1968 | | 52 | . | Bruce Peterson | 1968 |
| 53 | . | Steven Wagner | 1969 |
| 54 | . | Paul Hendricks | 1970 |
| 55 | . | Bernard Krossen | 1970 |
| 56 | . | Maurice Moore | 1970 |
| 57 | . | Arnold Krossen | 1972 |
| 58 | . | Byron Wagner | 1972 |
| 59 | . | George Wells | 1972 |
| 60 | . | James Wagner | 1972 |
| 61 | . | Victor Alfredson | 1973 |
| 62 | . | Bruce Templin | 1973 |
| 63 | . | Eddie Krossen | 1974 |
| 64 | . | Charles Galbreath | 1976 |
| 65 | . | James Rothermel | 1976 |
| 66 | . | Eric Anderson | 1977 |
| 67 | . | David Klinger | 1978 |
| 68 | . | David Cress | 1979 |
| 69 | . | Daniel Cress | 1981 |
| 70 | . | Kim Rask | 1983 |
| 71 | . | Mike Medema | 1983 |
| 72 | . | Patrick Hegge | 1986 |
| 73 | . | Howard Holt III | 1989 |
| 74 | . | John Davies | 1989 |
| 75 | . | David Aamodt | 1989 |
| 76 | . | Scott Fairbanks | 1990 |
| 77 | . | Jay See | 1990 |
| 78 | . | Jason Martin | 1990 |
| 79 | . | Michael Box | 1992 |
| 80 | . | Costa Nicolaidis | 1992 |
| 81 | . | Christian Omdal | 1992 |
| 82 | . | Andy Johnson | 1993 |
| 83 | . | Matt Galvin | 1993 |
| 84 | . | Andres Gilbert | 1993 |
| 85 | . | Benjamin Hansen | 1994 |
| 86 | . | Thomas Long | 1994 |
| 87 | . | Carl See | 1994 |
| 88 | . | Chad See | 1994 |
| 89 | . | Tim Merritt | 1994 |
| 90 | . | Eric Bruckbauer | 1995 |
| 91 | . | Steven Gilbert | 1995 |
| 92 | . | Travis Treser | 1995 |
| 93 | . | Johnnie Green | 1996 |
| 94 | . | Robert Monjay | 1996 |
| 95 | . | Michael Melgard | 1996 |
| 96 | . | Morgan Omdahl | 1996 |
| 97 | . | Thomas O'Hern | 1996 |
| 98 | . | Andrew Neyens | 1997 |
| 99 | . | Timothy Long | 1997 |
| 100 | . | Matt Neill | 1998 |
| 101 | . | Divven Browne | 1998 |
| 102 | . | William Sheehan | 1999 |
| 103 | . | Matthew Flowers | 1999 |
| 104 | . | Joel Trainor | 1999 |
| 105 | . | Kevin Neill | 2000 |
| 106 | . | Michael Helm | 2000 |
| 107 | . | Ryan Waters | 2000 |
| 108 | . | Reid Stillman | 2000 |
| 109 | . | Scott Robertson | 2000 |
| 110 | . | Dave O'Hern | 2000 |
| 111 | . | Jarod Brophy | 2001 |
| 112 | . | Kevin Riordan | 2001 |
| 113 | . | Kevin Keenholts | 2002 |
| 114 | . | Adam Kemly | 2002 |
| 115 | . | Marshall Nietcsche | 2002 |
| 116 | . | Mason Watt | 2003 |
| 117 | . | Travis Watt | 2003 |
| 118 | . | Patrick Stites | 2005 |
| 119 | . | Erik Geving | 2005 |
| 120 | . | Matt Renton | 2005 |
| 121 | . | Nicolas Olden | 2006 |
| 122 | . | Sean Yetter | 2006 |
| 123 | . | John Ver Wey | 2007 |
| 124 | . | William Van Zee | 2008 |
| 125 | . | Michael Petrucci | 2008 |
| 126 | . | Nathan Compton | 2008 |
| 127 | . | Brian Ver Wey | 2008 |
| 128 | . | Michael Roush | 2009 |
| 129 | . | Brendan Tarleton | 2010 |
| 130 | . | Sebastian Voorhees | 2010 |
| 131 | . | Sean Hendricks | 2010 |
| 132 | . | Alex Gonzales-Cress | 2011 |
| 133 | . | Tom Ryan | 2011 |
| 134 | . | Spencer Miller | 2011 |
| 135 | . | Max Golub | 2012 |
| 136 | . | Eric Hendricks | 2012 |
| 137 | . | Isaac Kent | 2012 |
| 138 | . | Ben Larson | 2012 |
| 139 | . | Stuart Gedosch | 2012 |
| 140 | . | Duncan Gowdy | 2013 |
| 141 | . | August Easton-Calabria | 2013 |
| 142 | . | Liam Easton-Calabria | 2013 |
| 143 | . | Wil Trainer | 2013 |
| 144 | . | Mac Stone | 2014 |
| 145 | . | Sam Ortiz | 2015 |
| 146 | . | Tommy Wicker-Fetzer | 2015 |
| 147 | . | Zach Dunkelberg | 2016 |
| 148 | . | Dylan McMurtry | 2016 |
| 149 | . | Mitchell Beardsley | 2016 |
| 150 | . | Satchel Dunnell | 2016 |
| 151 | . | Cole Pettit | 2016 |
| 152 | . | Marcel Foreman | 2016 |
| 153 | . | Gideon Wolfe | 2016 |
| 154 | . | Alex Hall | 2016 |
| 155 | . | Alex Putnam | 2016 |
| 156 | . | Birk Smith | 2017 |
| 157 | . | James Trainer | 2018 |
| 158 | . | Ian Harvey | 2018 |
| 159 | . | Daniel Peirce | 2018 |
| 160 | . | AnThu Nguyen | 2018 |
| 161 | . | Kevin Rogers | 2019 |
| 162 | . | Nate Vigdor | 2019 |
| 163 | . | Finn Pettit | 2020 |
| 164 | . | John Bentley | 2020 |
| 165 | . | Truman Wilson | 2020 |
| 166 | . | Casey Rogers | 2020 |
| 167 | . | John Jack McElearney | 2020 |
| 168 | . | Wilson Bailey | 2020 |
| 169 | . | Keyon Parks | 2021 |
| 170 | . | Gabe Trebach | 2021 |
| 171 | . | Aidan Zhou | 2021 |
| 172 | . | Luke Uniack | 2021 |
| 173 | . | Beau Berman | 2022 |
| 174 | . | Orion Iverson | 2022 |
| 175 | . | Rowan McCann | 2022 |
| 176 | . | Dabry Brillon | 2022 |
| 177 | . | Evan Wendel | 2022 |
| 178 | . | David Baylor | 2023 |
| 179 | . | Nikolas Prestegard | 2023 |
| 180 | . | Beck Pedersen | 2023 |
| 181 | . | Christian Varenhorst | 2023 |
| 182 | . | Taj Davis Rudin | 2023 |
| 183 | . | Tyler Place | 2023 |
| 184 | . | Joshua Place | 2023 |
| 185 | . | Sean Brine | 2023 |
